Algeria.com Discussion Forum - Powered by vBulletin


+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 7 of 7
  1. #1
    BACK2MYROOTS is offline Quarantined Users
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Leeds, West Yorkshire (UK)
    Posts
    379

    Question Muslim Superheroes: What are we doing to advance inter-cultural understanding?

    Assalamu 3aleikum

    Superman, Batman, etc...

    ... are the kinds of superheroes many of us have grown up with, admired and avidly read in comic books ,and watched in the cinemas in recent yeays. Naturally, these role models are essentially there to promote Western ideals and culture. The down side is that they tend to confirm Western cultural supremacy at the expense of other cultures, including Islamic culture.

    Not anymore!

    Now, we hear that our Muslim children are going to have their own glamorous Muslim Superheroes who are going to be not only better role models for them, but they will be also be designed to have a universal appeal to non-Muslims, too, we are told

    One can only admire and praise such efforts. Click on the link below for more info.

    The Ninety Nine - Heroes of Tomorrow? | Muslim Video Community

  2. #2
    Al-khiyal is offline Super Moderator
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    289,634
    w/salam akhi,

    You can get a free comic >>>here<<< and read a little more about them >>> here <<<

  3. #3
    Al-khiyal is offline Super Moderator
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    289,634

    Dubai, October 24, 2009 -- You know that Arab innovation has come a long way when superheroes created in Kuwait have the privilege of fighting evil alongside veterans like Superman and Batman. That is exactly what The 99, the Islamic superheroes created by Kuwaiti psychologist Nayef Al Mutawa, are about to do in a new comic book series to be launched by DC Comics. Al Mutawa has catapulted the series into the international limelight. Television giant Endemol has turned the series into an animated TV show. Much of its appeal has to do with the concept of the comic book, which has a story and a set of characters that are deeply Islamic yet entirely secular.

    Al Mutawa reached this delicate balance by introducing characters based on Islamic values that he says are universal. "Even atheists have those values. They don't tell their kids to lie three times a day," he says. While the characters reflect Islamic values, they are not necessarily Muslim, as religion is absent from the story. The superheroes come from 99 countries and their names reflect their ethnic backgrounds. "I will only consider this an achievement when a Muslim kid thinks these are Muslim characters, a Christian kid thinks they are Christian, a Jewish kid thinks they are Jewish and a Hindu thinks they are Hindu," he says.

    The story starts at a dark period of Islamic history associated with tragedy and decline. It is set in 1258. Abbasid Baghdad, one of the world's richest cities, is being sacked by the Mongol army of Hulagu Khan, grandson of Genghis Khan. The Mongols destroy the Bait al Hikma, the House of Wisdom, throwing its vast wealth of books and knowledge into the Tigris river, and marking the end of the Golden Age of Islam. The ink from the books, it is said, turns the river black for the next six months.

    A group of librarians from the Bait al Hikma are determined not to let the knowledge be lost forever. They drop 99 stones into the river to absorb the wisdom, to be known later as Noor Stones. A century later, after the Noor Stones make their way to Andalusia, the son of one of the guardians of the stones, Rughal discovers their extraordinary powers and plans to exploit them. He disappears, and so do the stones. In the present day, Rughal is found to be alive and bent on exploiting the stones' powers, and that is where 99 superheroes step in to stop him.

    Each superhero acquires powers from the stones that are loosely associated with the 99 attributes of God in Islam. Jabbar, the powerful, is a Saudi character who has extraordinary strength, Noora, the light, is an Emirati character that creates holograms, Mumita, a Portuguese character has martial arts skills. This did not come without its share of controversy with conservative Muslims accusing it of bid'a, innovation in worship or heresy, in associating God's attributes to human beings.

    But Al Mutawa rejects the notion that Islam is black and white. "The words bid'a [heresy] and ibda' [innovation] come from the same source. And the words fikr [thought] and kufr [infidelity] come from the same three letters. I don't think that's a coincidence," he says. What is he implying? "I'm implying that people in our culture try to make thinking and creativity into wrong and harmful things," he explains. He mentions the ministries of information in Arab countries "which are supposedly [banning] things to allow us to preserve our culture". "They are killing our culture," he says.

    The creativity he refers to is applying what he sees as the formula of comics in the West to the Islamic world. "Spiderman, Superman and Batman are based on Judeo-Christian archetypes. Like [some of] the prophets, all the superheroes are orphans; Batman is raised by an uncle. The prophets get the message from God through Gabriel, but Peter Parker is sitting in a library in Manhattan when a spider comes from above and gives him his message through a bite. Bruce Wayne is in his bedroom when a bat flies over his head. Superman not only gets his message from Krypton, the heavens, but when his father sends him to earth he says ‘I have sent to you my only son'. That's Jesus from the Bible," he says. Could that be coincidence? "No. All of them?" he says.

    But he does not consider these similarities as subliminal messages or a conspiracy to spread Christianity either. "This is about smart story telling. There are over a billion people who share a common education: the Bible. The old stories are built on a new architecture. They are familiar; they hit home." Al Mutawa went back to the Qur'an and applied the formula to Islamic history, where he found his villain, Rughal. The character's name is based on Abu Rughal, who in 550AD is said to have guided the Abyssinian emperor's Yemen governor Abraha to Makkah in the latter's effort to conquer the Holy City and destroy the Ka'aba. Abu Rughal is cited in Islamic history as a traitor. Since the people of Makkah could not defend the city against Abraha's 60,000-strong army, God, according to the Qur'an, sent birds that pelted the army with pebbles carried in their beaks.

    The 99 confront their enemy, Rughal, with the Noor stones. The alliance of Islamic superheroes with "Judeo-Christian archetype" superheroes is perhaps testament to Al Mutawa's insistence that The 99 is not an "us against them" project. For its critics, The 99 works to disprove conspiracy theories that the comic is an attempt to Islamise Western society, and claims in the Muslim world that the superheroes are an ungodly attempt to Westernise, or even Christianise young Muslims."We might be different on the behavioural level, but our values are the same," says Al Mutawa.

  4. #4
    New_Friend is offline Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Posts
    142
    "Rughal discovers their extraordinary powers and plans to exploit them" and "Each superhero acquires powers from the stones".....

    hmm...Sounds like a theme that predates all of Judaism, Christianity and Islam and is simply a spin of theologies much earlier -- Shintoism and Animism.

    <*yawn*, as I remember my parents' disdain for comics because they believed they "dumbed down" young readers and discouraged discovery of a deeper love for reading>

    Don't most kids have much more intriguing stories in their own unlimited imaginations and from reality?

  5. #5
    BACK2MYROOTS is offline Quarantined Users
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Leeds, West Yorkshire (UK)
    Posts
    379
    Quote Originally Posted by New_Friend View Post

    <*yawn*, as I remember my parents' disdain for comics because they believed they "dumbed down" young readers and discouraged discovery of a deeper love for reading>

    Don't most kids have much more intriguing stories in their own unlimited imaginations and from reality?

    Well well...
    'YAWN' ?!
    Woooowh! Maybe for you my friend, not for my generation. You have no idea how important comics were to people like me when we were young. So, each to their own. It is tempting to say that comics have had it now at the age of TV and the Internet. But this is probably not true. It would be plain silly to say that they are now as important to young people as they were say 30 or 40 years ago (that long ago!).


    In the olden days ...
    ... comics provided entertainment, education, and escapism. Ask your parents if they remember Bleck Le Rock, Akim, Zembla, Tarzan et bien d'autres...And they were not merely role models, I learnt French through them !!! Nobody forced me to read them. I loved them and read tons of them!


    You made some good points though.
    Having said that, nowadays it's all about diversity of choice, lots and lots of choice. There's room for everything.


    The BIG ISSUE today...

    ... is the so-called ''clash of civilizations''.

    This IS a fact. Western civilization, however wonderful it may be, is crushing all other civilizations, period. Islam and Islamic civilization have to counteract this threat. That's the thinking behind the creation of these new comics. I, personally, praise their awareness ,efforts and intentions. I think they are admirable. Disney is wonderful, I grew up with it, but an 'Islamic Disney' would be even better for our Muslim children. I am convinced of it 100%.

    Those are my views.

    B2MR
    Last edited by BACK2MYROOTS; 27th October 2009 at 13:57.

  6. #6
    Al-khiyal is offline Super Moderator
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    289,634

  7. #7
    New_Friend is offline Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Posts
    142
    Yes, some good points from you also, B2MR.

    In my generation, comics were a big thing, too, I think I simply never got interested, though, due to my parents' perspective (they were both teachers), and simply because I found them boring -- apart from the comics page in newspapers.

    But you made a really good point -- comics are VERY useful for people who are learning a second language, whether as kids or as adults. I learned a little bit of Nihongo this way.

    So, I'm currently studying Arabic. Can anyone recommend any non-religious themed (or overtoned) comics for beginning Arabic students?

    And on the subject, here's an interesting list of books for students of Kabyle -- includes some children's books:

    Idlisen-nne? (Collection HCA) | Scribd

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts